Home / The Wales Family

The Real Reason Behind King Charles's Tax Announcement — And It Is Not Transparency

While the tax reveal by King Charles is a much-needed step, the purpose behind it, might have a lot to do with the PR damage caused by Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor.

King Charles poses for an official portrait to mark the 50th anniversary of his Investiture taken at their Welsh residence Llwynywormwood on July 2, 2019 in Myddfai, Wales, United Kingdom. (Photo by Chris Jackson/Getty Images For Clarence House)
King Charles poses for an official portrait to mark the 50th anniversary of his Investiture taken at their Welsh residence Llwynywormwood on July 2, 2019 in Myddfai, Wales, United Kingdom. (Photo by Chris Jackson/Getty Images For Clarence House)

King Charles made history as the first sovereign to voluntarily share his tax bill. It was certainly a much-welcome change from the ages-old practices of the monarchy, but the reveal set a larger, much somber tone for discussion about what led to this moment. And the answers that have come up have been interesting, and much of it might have to do with disgraced royal, Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor. 

King Charles III stands after being crowned during his coronation ceremony in Westminster Abbey, on May 6, 2023, in London, England. (Image Source: Getty Images | Richard Pohle - WPA Pool)
King Charles stands after being crowned during his coronation ceremony in Westminster Abbey in London, England. (Image Source: Getty Images | Richard Pohle - WPA Pool)

It is no secret that the royal family has been dodging bullets and jumping over puddles for the past few years, with the Mountbatten-Windsor family playing a major role in the public debacle. Scotland correspondent for the i-Paper, Adam Forrest, recently wrote that although Charles is reportedly paying around $39.6 million USD in taxes since being crowned, “the move has been labeled by critics a ‘deliberate distraction’ from the terrible PR damage done to the Royal Family by his brother”. 

This year, it was revealed that Mountbatten-Windsor had earned personal income by subletting cottages at Royal Lodge, as part of his lease agreement. However, he was paying peppercorn rent. To add to that, it was further disclosed that the King was paying rent on Princess Beatrice and Princess Eugenie’s London properties. But the Yorks were only the start of the problems. “There was also anger over Charles’ Duchy of Lancaster and Prince William’s Duchy of Cornwall gaining huge rental income from grassroots groups, the NHS, and the military. The royal estates stopped charging grassroots groups following the criticism,” Forrest added. 

Image Source: Getty Images | Peter Nicholls
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor and King Charles engaged in a conversation while wearing their ceremonial robes (Image Source: Getty Images | Peter Nicholls)

Former minister and author of Royal Mint: National Debt, Norman Baker, said, “Andrew may have been the catalyst. But he is just a microcosm of the wider problem. There was terrible PR for Charles and William from the Duchies charging extortionate rents to everyone from the NHS to our armed forces to grassroots groups, which made them look grasping.” He further mentioned that important details such as Charles’ investments, income tax, capital gains tax, the source of the money, and how much is offset by expenses remain obscure. “It’s spin from the Palace in pretending to be transparent, partly in reaction to Andrew (controversies),” Baker added. 

Labor peer, George Foulkes, who “wants to bring down the taxpayer-funded Sovereign Grant”, believes that the tax reveal had been an attempt at gaining positive PR for the King. “The publication of tax returns is a welcome step, but I suspect it’s been done as a deliberate distraction. If they have these other income streams, there’s no reason they can’t pay for more themselves,” he said. 

Image Source: Getty Images I Yui Mok - Pool
King Charles giving a speech during his visit to Bermuda in 2026 (Image Source: Getty Images I Yui Mok - Pool)

Charles willingly pays tax on the private income generated from the Duchy of Lancaster, a portfolio of properties, land, and other assets. Other than that, he owns the Balmoral and Sandringham estates and has other personal, private investments. There is no doubt that the royal family is a soft power for the UK and benefits the economy by encouraging tourism. But the purpose of the tax reveal and the continued lack of clarity over other significant financial details have raised eyebrows. 

GET BREAKING ROYAL NEWS
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

More Stories

Princess Kate is finally opening up about the most difficult phase of her life, which is her battle with cancer and the period after.
By Medha Sengupta · 4 HOURS AGO
The 'Children's Princess,' Princess Kate of the UK, did not miss the opportunity to celebrate the UN's World Children's Day with special portraits.
By Medha Sengupta · 1 DAY AGO
Kate Middleton's royal wardrobe involves careful planning, trusted designers and a personal approach that goes beyond following fashion trends.
By Hrishita Das · 1 DAY AGO
The Indian trip was special for more reasons than one, as it was Kate's first overseas engagement with William since her cancer diagnosis.
By Medha Sengupta · 1 DAY AGO
The Duchess of Gloucester made a rare appearance alongside Charles and Camilla, choosing a bold red look for the occasion.
By Hrishita Das · 2 DAYS AGO
Kate Middleton's love for Mahima Mahajan's original Anarkali design meant the Princess wanted very few changes to it.
By Hrishita Das · 2 DAYS AGO
EXCLUSIVE ANALYSIS: Kate's India wardrobe brought together British designers, Indian jewelry, and sustainable materials, with each outfit carrying a possible nod to her hosts, our expert decodes.
By Hrishita Das · 2 DAYS AGO
Prince William and Princess Kate are in for a major diplomatic meeting with PM Modi as they bring their three-day visit to India to an end.
By Medha Sengupta · 3 DAYS AGO
William and Kate got crafty in Mumbai, trying their hands at block printing and creating floral designs on silk scarves.
By Hrishita Das · 3 DAYS AGO
Princess Kate spent her Wednesday afternoon learning about an important cause that she has been working towards for years.
By Ira Deokule · 3 DAYS AGO