Link to Facebook Link to Instagram Link to X Link to YouTube
The Royal Observer
THE SUSSEX FAMILY THE WALES FAMILY EXCLUSIVES ROYAL NEWS OPINION THE KING THE QUEEN
PHOTO GALLERY LIVE BLOGS VIDEOS
Link to Facebook Link to Instagram Link to X Link to YouTube
Home / Galleries

4 Ways Former Prince Andrew’s Legal Fight With the Police Could Play Out

Features & Scandals Oct 6, 2026
BY HRISHITA DAS
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor leaves the headquarters of Crossrail at Canary Wharf on March 7, 2011 in London, England. (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Jonathan Buckmaster)
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor leaves the headquarters of Crossrail at Canary Wharf on March 7, 2011 in London, England. (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Jonathan Buckmaster)
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor has taken on the police, but the result could play out in many ways, and not all of them are pretty.
5 Photos
1 / 5
Andrew Fights Back
IMAGE SOURCE: IMAGE SOURCE: GETTY IMAGES | JORDAN PETTITT

Andrew Fights Back

Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor is fighting back against the police after officers searched properties linked to him earlier this year. The former Prince was arrested on February 19 over allegations of misconduct in public office and was questioned before being released while the investigation continued. Police searched Royal Lodge and another property on the Sandringham Estate that same day. Now, Mountbatten-Windsor’s lawyers are challenging the warrants that gave officers permission to carry out those searches. With the investigation still ongoing, the legal battle could play out in many ways, and not all of them are pretty.

2 / 5
The Police Win
IMAGE SOURCE: IMAGE SOURCE: GETTY IMAGES | GARETH CATTERMOLE

The Police Win

The first possibility is that the High Court decides Thames Valley Police did nothing wrong when it searched Mountbatten-Windsor's properties. The searches of his home on the Sandringham Estate and Royal Lodge were carried out under warrants issued by a judge. The court will look at whether police had a good enough reason to carry out the searches and whether officers stayed within the limits of the warrants. Legal commentator Joshua Rozenberg told Sky News that the court will also consider whether police followed the proper process and could show that searching the properties was necessary for a “prompt and effective investigation.” If everything checks out, the disgraced former Prince’s legal challenge would fail, and police could continue their investigation using the material they collected during the searches.

3 / 5
Legal Grey Area
IMAGE SOURCE: IMAGE SOURCE: GETTY IMAGES | MAX MUMBY

Legal Grey Area

Things get a little more complicated if the High Court decides the searches were unlawful. That would not necessarily mean that any material found during the search is automatically off the table. Thames Valley Police could argue that it should still be allowed to keep the material collected during the searches. Criminal lawyer Nick Vamos told the BBC that when police have lost challenges over search warrants because of a technical error, they have sometimes still been allowed to keep the material they found. He said, “The police can apply back to the Crown Court to retain the material if they have grounds to immediately seize it again.” So, even if the ex-Prince manages to prove that something went wrong with the searches, that would not necessarily mean the evidence simply disappears.

4 / 5
Potential Win
IMAGE SOURCE: IMAGE SOURCE: GETTY IMAGES | LEON NEAL

Potential Win

There is also a scenario where the court could side with Mountbatten-Windsor and decide that police should return material taken during the searches. It could even stop Thames Valley Police from relying on that material in any future case against him. But that would not be an automatic result. The former Duke’s legal team could also push for the evidence to be kept out of any future proceedings against him. Dai Davies, who previously headed Scotland Yard’s Royal Protection Command, told iPaper, “It’s a possible strategy that I suspect they may be trying to pursue.” In other words, a win in the High Court could potentially go beyond simply proving that the searches were unlawful. Mountbatten-Windsor could also try to make sure anything found during those searches cannot later be used against him.

5 / 5
A Payout?
IMAGE SOURCE: IMAGE SOURCE: GETTY IMAGES | KARWAI TANG/WIREIMAGE

A Payout?

If the High Court finds that the police searches were unlawful, the former Duke could potentially take things a step further and seek compensation for what happened. According to iPaper, John Hagan, a partner at DPP Law, said that the legal challenge could be “a precursor step to suing for substantial compensation.” He suggested the amount could be significant, potentially ranging from around £1,500 to “tens of thousands of pounds.” However, getting compensation would not necessarily make the police investigation disappear. Hagan said, “There are two separate things: you can be under suspicion of an offence, and it could be that the search warrant for your property is obtained unlawfully in some way.”

MORE GALLERIES

4 Photos of King Charles and Queen Camilla Stealing the Spotlight at the Royal Variety Performance 5

4 Photos of King Charles and Queen Camilla Stealing the Spotlight at the Royal Variety Performance

Nov 21, 2026
5 Photos of Princess Kate’s Best Fashion Moments as She and Prince William Wrap Their India Tour 6

5 Photos of Princess Kate’s Best Fashion Moments as She and Prince William Wrap Their India Tour

Nov 18, 2026
4 Photos From Mumbai That Prove Prince William and Princess Kate Are Smitten With Each Other 5

4 Photos From Mumbai That Prove Prince William and Princess Kate Are Smitten With Each Other

Nov 17, 2026
4 Photos of Prince William Driving Kate Around in a Rickshaw That Prove He's the Ultimate Gentleman 5

4 Photos of Prince William Driving Kate Around in a Rickshaw That Prove He's the Ultimate Gentleman

Nov 17, 2026
4 Photos of Princess Kate Playing Cricket Like a Pro in Mumbai 5

4 Photos of Princess Kate Playing Cricket Like a Pro in Mumbai

Nov 16, 2026
5 Adorable Moments From Kate’s Latest Outing That Show Why She’s the 'Children’s Princess' 5

5 Adorable Moments From Kate’s Latest Outing That Show Why She’s the 'Children’s Princess'

Nov 11, 2026
4 Sweet Ways Prince Harry Had Meghan’s Back in Brussels After She Pulled Out of Speech 5

4 Sweet Ways Prince Harry Had Meghan’s Back in Brussels After She Pulled Out of Speech

Nov 10, 2026
All the Hidden Tributes Princess Kate Made During Remembrance Weekend 4

All the Hidden Tributes Princess Kate Made During Remembrance Weekend

Nov 9, 2026
5 Awkward Photos of Queen Camilla and Princess Kate Breaking Protocol at Remembrance Sunday 5

5 Awkward Photos of Queen Camilla and Princess Kate Breaking Protocol at Remembrance Sunday

Nov 9, 2026
5 Recent Pictures That Show How Close Prince William and Prince George Really Are 5

5 Recent Pictures That Show How Close Prince William and Prince George Really Are

Nov 4, 2026
5 Powerful Things King Charles Said in His Commonwealth Address That Stood Out 6

5 Powerful Things King Charles Said in His Commonwealth Address That Stood Out

Nov 3, 2026
5 Striking Photos of King Charles Braving the Rain in Antigua 5

5 Striking Photos of King Charles Braving the Rain in Antigua

Nov 2, 2026
4 Allegedly Haunted Royal Residences — and the One Queen Camilla Was Afraid to Revisit 6

4 Allegedly Haunted Royal Residences — and the One Queen Camilla Was Afraid to Revisit

Oct 31, 2026
5 Times the Royal Family Played Dressed Up in Halloween Costumes 6

5 Times the Royal Family Played Dressed Up in Halloween Costumes

Oct 30, 2026
5 Pictures of King Charles Showing His Rare Relaxed Side in Nassau 6

5 Pictures of King Charles Showing His Rare Relaxed Side in Nassau

Oct 29, 2026
5 Things King Charles Did to Win Over the Caribbean Amid Protests 6

5 Things King Charles Did to Win Over the Caribbean Amid Protests

Oct 28, 2026
5 Worrying Photos of King Charles as He Lands in the Bahamas for Grueling Tour 5

5 Worrying Photos of King Charles as He Lands in the Bahamas for Grueling Tour

Oct 28, 2026
4 Royal Visits to the Caribbean That Triggered Backlash 5

4 Royal Visits to the Caribbean That Triggered Backlash

Oct 27, 2026
4 Things Prince William’s Graham Norton Appearance Changed for the Monarchy 5

4 Things Prince William’s Graham Norton Appearance Changed for the Monarchy

Oct 26, 2026
4 Major Decisions King Charles Reportedly Regrets 5

4 Major Decisions King Charles Reportedly Regrets

Oct 25, 2026
About Contact Privacy Policy Terms Editorial Policy
Google Preferred Website
SUBSCRIBE
Subscribe to The Royal Observer Newsletter
Subscribe to The Royal Observer YouTube
Subscribe to The Royal Observer on Flipboard
Follow Us
Link to Facebook
Link to X
Link to Instagram
Link to YouTube
The Royal Observer
© Copyright 2026 THE ROYAL OBSERVER™️. A DIVISION OF SCALE CONTENT INC. THE ROYAL OBSERVER is a registered trademark. All rights reserved. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service, Privacy Policy and Cookies Policy. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services. Offers may be subject to change without notice.