Home / THE QUEEN

Queen Elizabeth Wasn't of Sound Mind When Andrew Settled Lawsuit With Virginia Giuffre: Author

A royal author has challenged the long-held assumption that Queen Elizabeth personally brokered the 2022 settlement between Mountbatten-Windsor and Giuffre.

Queen Elizabeth and Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor attend Derby Day of the Investec Derby Festival. (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Max Mumby/Indigo)
Queen Elizabeth and Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor attend Derby Day of the Investec Derby Festival. (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Max Mumby/Indigo)

For years, the story of Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor’s multi-million dollar settlement with Virginia Giuffre has centred on the late Queen Elizabeth’s final acts of maternal protection. However, royal author Andrew Lownie is now upending that timeline, arguing that the late monarch may have lacked the mental capacity to authorize the deal — meaning King Charles likely orchestrated the entire agreement.

Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Andrew, Duke of York watch a flypast from the balcony of Buckingham Palace during Trooping The Colour. (Image Source: Getty Images | Max Mumby)
Queen Elizabeth II and Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor watch a flypast from the balcony of Buckingham Palace during Trooping the Color. (Image Source: Getty Images | Max Mumby)

Speaking on The Royalist podcast, the royal author shared fresh insights into Queen Elizabeth’s final moments — challenging the long-held assumption that she personally brokered the 2022 settlement between Mountbatten-Windsor and Giuffre, estimated to be around $16 million. He suggested that her declining health made such a complex legal task almost impossible, noting that she was far less involved than the Palace let on. Lownie’s claims are grounded in a conversation with one of the last non-staff members to spend significant time with her — a guest who was given a blunt heads-up before their meeting. “And this person was told before they went in to meet her, 'Listen, I want to warn you, she can't really see very much,” the royal author states. 

The visitor, as per Lownie, was also told that the Queen was largely confined to her quarters, frequently drifted between the present and the past, and became tired very easily. “The extent to which she wasn't fully compos mentis, I think, does make it…inconceivable that Charles was not involved in that settlement.” By framing the late monarch as an elderly woman who was “dropping in and out of the past,” Lownie argues that the Palace’s claim of Charles’s ignorance regarding the deal is no longer tenable — with the author observing, “It is just inconceivable that this wasn't run past Charles at a minimum.” 

Prince Andrew, Duke of York and Prince Charles, Prince of Wales attend the Order of the Garter Service at St George's Chapel in Windsor Castle. (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Peter Nicholls - WPA Pool)
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor and King Charles attend the Order of the Garter Service at St George's Chapel in Windsor Castle. (Image Source: Getty Images | Peter Nicholls - WPA Pool)

The 2022 settlement — a massive payout intended to end Virginia Giuffre’s civil lawsuit against Mountbatten-Windsor — has long been a magnet for scrutiny, especially regarding the source of the funds and the final architect of the strategy. Lownie is quite blunt about the true motivation behind the deal. “That settlement effectively was done to buy Virginia Giuffre's silence. I mean, that's what the purpose of it was,” he added. The ‘Andrew problem’ was no sudden catastrophe; it was, according to the royal author, a two-decade-long failure of Palace oversight. 

By 2005, royal security was already in overdrive, “shutting down all sorts of stories about Andrew,” while a near-revolt brewed within the Foreign Office over the ex-Duke’s behavior as a trade envoy. “So everyone knew, everything was reported back, and everyone at the Palace stuck their head in the sand,” Lownie said, stating, “They'd been aware of the problem for a long time…[Andrew] was actually counterproductive to what they were doing.” 

Andrew Mountbatten Windsor attends day eleven of the Wimbledon Tennis Championship. (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Karwai Tang/WireImage)
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor attends day eleven of the Wimbledon Tennis Championship. (Image Source: Getty Images | Karwai Tang/WireImage)

Lownie’s research suggests a Palace in transition long before Queen Elizabeth’s passing — a period where the then-Prince of Wales likely had to step into the vacuum left by his mother’s declining health. In this light, the Giuffre deal wasn’t a mother saving a son; it was a King-in-waiting protecting the institution from a fire he had been watching burn for over two decades. 

GET BREAKING ROYAL NEWS
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

More Stories

Today's event also saw the launch of the Children’s Booker Prize, which aims to foster a new generation of readers.
By Mary Anthony · 5 DAYS AGO
The Queen was spotted acting like a local during one of the community visits.
By Mary Anthony · NOV 4, 2026
Queen Camilla has always been vocal on issues that resonate with her, whether standing up to domestic violence or promoting education.
By Medha Sengupta · NOV 3, 2026
Camilla joined Charles only for the last leg of his nine-day Caribbean tour.
By Mary Anthony · NOV 2, 2026
Sometimes, even an unexpected downpour can turn into a moment worth smiling about. Queen Camilla proved exactly that.
By Medha Sengupta · NOV 2, 2026
Queen Camilla, who was absent during the first half of the trip, reunited with the monarch at V.C. Bird International Airport on Saturday.
By Mary Anthony · NOV 2, 2026
Queen Camilla carried a bit of Royal history with her by opting for the late Queen’s favorite tiara.
By Mehak Walia · OCT 21, 2026
Braving the autumn rain, Camilla wore a crimson wool crepe dress and matching coat, custom-made by one of her favorite designers, Fiona Clare.
By Mary Anthony · OCT 20, 2026
Zara and Camilla were seen spending a lovely afternoon together, chatting and laughing in between races.
By Mary Anthony · OCT 19, 2026
Queen Camilla recently visited Wales, and who could be better style inspirations than the Prince and Princess of Wales?
By Ira Deokule · OCT 15, 2026