Home / OPINION / Scandal

Expert Calls Out Prince Edward For His 'Pathetic Royal Reaction' to the Andrew Scandal

Instead of clarity or accountability, Edward’s comments on the scandal amounted to what a royal expert describes as a deeply flawed and tone-deaf.

(L)Prince Edward attends Coral Gold Cup Day at Newbury Racecourse; (R) Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor leaving St. Giles Cathedral; (Inset) Jeffrey Epstein in Cambridge. Cover Image Source: Getty Images | (L) Max Mumby; (R) Samir Hussein; (Inset) Rick Friedman
(L)Prince Edward attends Coral Gold Cup Day at Newbury Racecourse; (R) Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor leaving St. Giles Cathedral; (Inset) Jeffrey Epstein in Cambridge. Cover Image Source: Getty Images | (L) Max Mumby; (R) Samir Hussein; (Inset) Rick Friedman

Trigger Warning: This article contains themes of sexual abuse that some readers may find distressing.

Prince Edward may have broken the royal family’s long-held rule of ‘never complain, never explain,’ but according to royal commentator Tom Sykes, what followed was far from meaningful as he fell short of owning up. Instead of clarity or accountability, Edward’s comments on the Andrew-Epstein scandal amounted to what Sykes describes as a deeply flawed and tone-deaf intervention – one that said little, and yet managed to expose just how far the monarchy still is from confronting the issue head-on.

Prince Edward, attends the 98th Combined Cavalry Old Comrades Association annual parade and service in Hyde Park . (Image Source: Max Mumby/Indigo)
Prince Edward attends the 98th Combined Cavalry Old Comrades Association annual parade and service in Hyde Park. (Image Source: Getty Images | Max Mumby/Indigo)

In response to Edward’s remarks, Skyes took to his Substack, noting that much of the British media rushed to applaud the Duke of Edinburgh for speaking at all. He was far less impressed. “The British media have rushed to salute Prince Edward (WHO? as football fans bellow en masse when an unknown player is subbed on by the other side) for what I found to be a notably mealy-mouthed and pathetic first royal public reaction to the new Epstein files,” Sykes wrote, adding that the documents “have exposed Andrew’s involvement in what looks very like a sex trafficking ring.” 

For Sykes, Edward’s comments did not signal progress or accountability. Quite the opposite. “In the world of terrible royal non-apologies, this, for me, rather than representing some gleaming new era of accountability, is actually a new low,” he wrote.

Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor lying across row of women in photo during black-tie event with Ghislaine Maxwell has been released as part of the Epstein files.
Department of Justice
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor, lying across a row of women in a photo during a black-tie event with Ghislaine Maxwell, has been released as part of the Epstein files. (Image Source: US Department of Justice)

Edward made the remarks while speaking at the World Governments Summit in Dubai, where he was asked how he was coping with the renewed fallout from the Epstein revelations. Rather than addressing the substance of the allegations, Edward appeared to minimize the moment, suggesting the setting was ill-suited for the topic. 

“Well, with the best will in the world, I’m not sure this is the audience that is probably the least bit interested in that,” Edward told the CNN journalist. “They all came here to listen to education, solving the future, but no, I think it’s all really important always to remember the victims, and who are the victims in all this? A lot of victims in this.” And it is the phrasing, about Edward's apparent uncertainty about who the victims were, that draws Skyes’s ire. While Edward spoke about the importance of remembering victims, Sykes argued that he simultaneously diluted the point by refusing to be specific.

Andrew Mountbatten -Windsor in full ceremonial uniform, and his brother, Prince Edward attend the outdoor service commemorating the fiftieth anniversary of VJ Day, on The Mall, London, England. (Image Source: Tim Graham)
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor, in full ceremonial uniform, and his brother, Prince Edward, attend the outdoor service commemorating the fiftieth anniversary of VJ Day, on The Mall, London. (Image Source: Getty Images | Tim Graham)

“While talking about the need to ‘remember the victims,’ he seemed to question who they were,” Sykes wrote, before cutting to the heart of the issue. “WTF? Like, who else, other than the women and girls who were abused, are you thinking of, Edward? Come on, tell us!”

The criticism comes at a moment when the details emerging from the Epstein files are increasingly graphic and disturbing. Among the latest disclosures are images that reportedly show Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor crouched over a woman lying on the floor, along with screengrabs of him suggesting he emailed Epstein about a 'beautiful' Russian woman and invited him to Buckingham Palace. Mountbatten Windsor’s former wife, Sarah Ferguson, is also referenced in the newly released material.

If you are being subjected to sexual abuse, or know of anyone who is, please call the National Sexual Assault Hotline at 800.656.HOPE (4673)

GET BREAKING ROYAL NEWS
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

More Stories

Royal expert Ailsa Anderson believed the King should avoid meeting Andrew as it would only bring his scandals "back to the surface again."
By Andrea Cutinho · 1 DAY AGO
Royal expert Emily Nash explained how Prince William and Kate Middleton's crucial partnership helps them navigate the rough waters.
By Andrea Cutinho · 3 DAYS AGO
Royal expert Tom Sykes believes Sarah Ferguson's dire financial situation could spell trouble for the royal family if she pulls off one move.
By Andrea Cutinho · 3 DAYS AGO
Royal expert Andrew Lownie says the former Duke of York thinks he is untouchable and unwilling to accept that his actions carry consequences. 
By Andrea Cutinho · 4 DAYS AGO
Historian says King Charles and Prince William must define the monarchy’s role before 'little marginal attacks' destroy it.
By Abha Anindita · 6 DAYS AGO
Royal expert Andrew Lownie claims Russian intelligence services exploited Andrew's personal network to gain influence in Western capitals.
By Andrea Cutinho · FEB 27, 2026
Royal expert Cameron Walker believed that Prince William, who is 'deeply concerned' about Andrew's arrest, is forced to put on a brave face.
By Andrea Cutinho · FEB 24, 2026
Royal expert Ingrid Seward opined of Sarah Ferguson, "She is busy looking after number one. I doubt we'll see her for a while."
By Andrea Cutinho · FEB 23, 2026
Experts say detention of the monarch’s brother poses a serious test for the Crown.
By Abha Anindita · FEB 20, 2026
After emails exposing Beatrice's advice on repairing ties with Epstein surfaced, Prince William is reconsidering his previously lenient stance.
By Andrea Cutinho · FEB 19, 2026